Cadence
OrCAD X
Data Protection
 
Data Sharing
Improved Decision Making
 
Reuse
Reduction in Redundancy

Pros

Cons

  • Simple, no extra infrastructure or databases needed
  • Flexible organization that’s user-defined
  • Quick to set up, replicate, and share
  • Accessible offline
  • Decentralized libraries result in inconsistencies
  • Risk of outdated or mismatched components
  • Lacks scalability across multiple users/groups
  • Lacks traceability

Pros

Cons

  • Centralized ODBC database
  • Links to PLM for part management
  • Easy to populate database using Component Information Portal (CIP)
  • Components linked to parametric data and models
  • Ideal for teams where consistency is critical
  • Requires database setup and maintenance
  • Requires internet and/or network access
  • Requires database licenses and possibly additional hardware
  • Higher learning curve
  • No version management

Pros

Cons

  • Libraries are always up to date with cloud sync
  • Multi-user collaboration with access control
  • Accessible anywhere with backup protection from hardware failures
  • Version controlled ensuring traceability
  • No additional hardware or database cost
  • Requires internet access
  • Data portability restricted
  • Limited out of the box 3rd party integration – API availability